Questions in Comments
Mark a comment as a question, give it an optional date it needs an answer by, tell the right people, and mark it answered when it is settled.
On this page
What questions are for#
Some comments are not remarks but questions that hold work up: Which payment providers do we support at launch? Mark a comment like that as a question and it stops being lost in the thread. It carries a badge, it can have a date it needs an answer by, the people who follow the work are told it was asked, and it stays open until someone marks it answered. The Weekly Look-ahead report then shows every open question in the week it matters.
You can mark a comment as a question on a work item (a story, defect, ticket or any other item) and on a Knowledge Base article, in its review comments.
Marking a comment as a question#
- Choose the comment that starts the thread. Replies cannot be questions on their own.
- Click the Question icon (a question mark; its tooltip says Mark as a question) in the comment's footer.
- Leave This is a question switched on. If you need the answer by a certain day, pick it under Need an answer by (optional).
- Click Save.
The comment now shows a Question badge, or Question · need by and the date. To change the date, or turn the question back into an ordinary comment, click the icon again (its tooltip now says Question settings), change the date or switch This is a question off, and click Save.
You can mark your own comments, if you can edit them (Manage Own Comments). Holders of Manage All Comments on work items, or Moderate knowledge-base article comments on articles, can mark anyone's. Marking a comment as a question does not count as editing it, so you can also mark a public reply on a ticket that has already been sent.
Who is told a question was asked#
When a comment is marked as a question, the people that comment already notifies are told a question was asked, with its need-by date if it has one and the work it belongs to:
- On a work item: the item's creator, its assignee, the people taking part in it, and its watchers. The notification links to the item.
- On a Knowledge Base article: the article's author and the people who watch it or a category above it. The notification names the work items the article is linked to, but only the ones each person can open.
Nobody is told about a question they marked themselves, or about one they cannot read. Notifications follow each person's settings for Comments modified. If the question is unmarked, answered or deleted before the notification goes out, nobody is told.
Marking a question answered#
A question is answered when its thread is settled.
- On a work item, click Mark answered (a check mark) on the question. The badge turns green and reads Answered, and DevStride records who answered it and when. Click Reopen question to put it back if the answer did not hold. The person who asked, the item's assignee (usually the one who answers), and holders of Manage All Comments can do this.
- On a Knowledge Base article, resolve the thread as you would any other. A resolved question counts as answered; reopening the thread reopens it.
Where a question belongs#
A question on a work item belongs to that item. A question on a Knowledge Base article belongs to the work items the article is linked to, so it shows up with that work in the Weekly Look-ahead. A question on an article with no linked work still notifies people, but has no work to appear under.